Does Cuba Sink When We Hear the Truth?
HAVANA TIMES – Arnaldo Mirabal announced on social networks that he is quitting journalism. He does so a few days after being threatened with being taken to court for writing about a case of alleged corruption of a political leader in the province of Matanzas.
The provincial authorities throw a blanket of silence over this case. They don’t clarify why that person was removed as the head of the city’s government or why she now holds another position of responsibility. Instead, they confirm the theory of ordinary Cubans about managers and leaders, who they say defy gravity and fall upwards.
Granma newspaper’s deputy director, Karina Marrón, said on Facebook that “Arnaldo and the people of Matanzas have the right to know what happened, whether there was corruption or not, or whatever the reasons were for this person no longer holding the position people chose her for.”
After a year of requesting information about the removal of Marta Odalys, carried out in secret by the authorities of Matanzas, the response obtained by journalist Arnaldo Mirabal is a little veiled threat, “you have no evidence and Marta Odalys can sue you for defamation.”
This is not the first time that the corrupt are protected by persecuting the messenger who dares to reveal the truth. Professor Esteban Morales was separated from the Communist Party for the same reason, he requested information about leaders being deposed without explanation.
Morales was allowed back into the Party after appealing his removal at all the channels within his reach and with the support of alternative media and academia. However, they then limited his participation in the national media, despite being a highly respected specialist in Cuba-US relations.
Recently, Harold Cardenas, a founder of the jovencuba blog, announced that he was leaving Cuba to study at Columbia University in the USA. He was one of the main targets of extremists, who now revel with articles saying that this young intellectual is a “political corpse.”
In his farewell, Harold shows us some of his fears: “When there is more fear than money, more sleeplessness than solutions, Cuba contracts and the excesses begin. It was not difficult to imagine who would be the collateral damage and I applied to several universities abroad. ”
In addition to these cases of intimidation, is the prohibition of journalists working with a government media also contributing with an alternative media; the letter of protest from the young journalists of Villa Clara, and the dismissal in Holguin of journalist Jose Ramirez Pantoja for publishing on his blog the words of the deputy director of Granma, the official organ of the Communist Party.
And intolerance is increasing; even Second Cita, the blog of singer/songwriter Silvio Rodriguez was targeted by extremist groups. They try to get Silvio to stop publishing the opinions of intellectuals silenced by the official press, even though some of them are recognized revolutionaries and Marxists.
These are desperate attempts to keep control over what is published, but in the long run such is a futile effort. The advance of the Internet is unstoppable and opens to Cubans the widest international information spectrum, from the New Herald to Rebellion.
But the Defenders of the Faith continue winning Pyrrhic battles, the same ones that the Nation loses. Cuba loses when its young people emigrate; when the supposed Defenders kill their hope of building a better world, when they are threatened to be silent in the face of corruption.
Something is not right in a society when corrupt politicians “move on to occupy new posts” and journalists are punished for denouncing them. Silence about white-collar crime is a path already transited by other Latin American countries, and it is easy to see where it leads us.
Censors, who always justify themselves by saying that their job is to “defend the revolution by not giving weapons to the enemy,” now, paradoxically, seem to be defending corruption and robbing the people of the main weapon to combat it, transparency.
And now, what will those censors do with Arnaldo Mirabal?, accuse him of being a counterrevolutionary ?, expel him from the Communist Party like Esteban Morales ?, take away his Internet access to annul his blog? or will they try to discredit him with suitably inflated trivia?
I think of Arnaldo and remember the words of Fidel Castro early on in the Revolution: “We were married to the lie and it forced us to live with it. That is why when we hear the truth it seems to us that the world is sinking.”
In response to your point: “I cannot believe that there is not someone on the island of Cuba who does not possess a vision of a much better future for all of the Cuban people”, I can assure you that I know several.
But the Castro regime has for fifty eight years pursued and established political management systems to prevent such people from pursuing any such visions. The CDR and its supervisory body MININT are there continuously on every block of every village, town and city. The threat of arbitary arrest, a visit to Villa Marista for extraction of confession and jail without trial create that justified fear that you described.
It is ordinary human behaviour for decent people to wish to improve their lot for themselves, their families and for those you mention, their country.
The Castro regime has learned from the experiences of Hungary in 1956, Czechoslovakia in1968 and the implosion of the USSR in 1989/90. They have observed both China and Vietnam turning to capitalism, but have rigidly adhered to Stalinist type communism. Yes, there was some easing of restriction when Raul wanted to reduce the State wage bill and allowed a slight degree of self-employment. But even that was prevented from extension on August 8 from which date no further licenses have been issued.
I say all this in defence of those Cubans who have hope of introducing change in Cuba, but are gripped so tightly in the communist vice.
Corruption under Castro? Surely not! MR Castro both present and past have managed to maintain a stranglehold on the Cuban people for far too long. The Cuban people deserve so much better, and no not from America or the west but from within. I cannot believe that their is not someone on the island of Cuba who does not possess a vision of a much better future for all of the Cuban people in and on Cuba? Prosperity for the people and by the people, not just the corrupt few who rule by fear!
‘Che’ Guevara said:
“We must do away with all newspapers. A revolution cannot be accomplished with freedom of the press.”
Fidel Castro in a speech given on August 13th, 1968 criticizing the revolution by freedom fighters in Czechoslovakia against Communism and when Russia rolled in the tanks, said:
“Certain measures were taken such as the establishment of a bourgeois form of freedom of the press.This means the counterrevolution and the exploiters, the very enemies of socialism, were granted the right to speak and write freely against socialism.”
This tyrannical view clearly defines Fidel Castro’s opposition to the expression of individual opinion other than his own.
That censorious view and policy is still very much enforced in Cuba today and Cuba is one of the seven most censored countries in the world.
But, the cell phone lurks and a fortunate few even have access to limited Internet !
Thank you for the article Fernando Ravsberg.
Information is the enemy of communism.