author photo

Erasmo Calzadilla: My parents named me Erasmo 34 year ago, when I was planted in a neighborhood of retired military personnel situated toward the southern city limits of Havana. I don’t know why, but I’m impassioned with thought, philosophy, art, science, friendship and music; in short, everything good that has stirred the passions of humans, nature, and God – or whoever was the creator. Actually I graduated in pharmacy, but I work as a professor at institutions that believe in me and are welcoming. It is important to highlight that I also hold a well-defined political position: I am a bitter opponent of those who are bossy, abusive, and imposing, those who believe they hold the truth, etc., independent of their attire. To them, I occasionally dedicate a few angry words.

Mandela: A Multifaceted Symbol

December 11, 2013 | Print Print |

I didn’t want to be presented in a way that omits the dark spots in my life.  -Nelson Mandela

Erasmo Calzadilla

Nelson Mandela. Photo: wikipedia.org

HAVANA TIMES — Mandela was a man and a symbol: an icon of the struggle against apartheid and injustice, but also a case study that shows us how “the apparatus” can subordinate even its most astute opponents to its own interests.

The apartheid regime was getting very bad press before the South African leader had become the country’s president. Even those who supported the South African government economically (I am thinking of the country’s ally, the United States) were losing face before international public opinion.

The struggle against institutional racism was a vigorous movement that was much talked about around the world.

Many believed that Mandela’s presidency would spell the end of segregation, or at least the beginning of true, radical change in the country. Today, twenty years after Mandela took office, one question imposes itself on us: can we legitimately claim that apartheid* is over in South Africa?

I won’t overwhelm you with statistics but I will only share some facts with you: 80% of the land is still in the hands of the white elite, South Africa is one of the countries with the greatest social inequalities in the world (according to the Gini index) and unemployment borders on 40%. I wonder what race most of the poor and unemployed in the country belong to?

With his faith and participation in the political games of bourgeois democracy, Mandela used his brilliant reputation to clean up the reputation of a system that is and will continue to be ruthless with those whose lot is to slither at the lowest steps of the social pyramid.

Perhaps he should have never accepted the presidency, if he knew that was not conducive to a true revolution in the country’s distribution of power.

Today, South Africa’s exploitative, export-based apparatus can continue to ground up poor blacks and whites without as many obstacles as before.

* We can take “apartheid” to mean, not only a concrete phenomenon that took place in a given region and at a given point in history, based on a certain set of principles and enforced through the use of barbed wire and other means, but also segregation in general.


What's your opinion?

  • John Goodrich

    South Africa is at peace with the United States only because it chose to remain with the same capitalist economy that enriches the very few and impoverishes the majority who live on U.S.$2.00 a day .
    Those conditions, for the majority of people living in a country with large gold and diamond deposits will not only remain unchanged for the future but will continue to deteriorate as capitalists worldwide take in an ever-higher percentage of the wealth .
    In the U.S. the top 1% took in some 90% of all the wealth created since the big recession supposedly ended and wealth inequality in South Africa is even worse.
    Let’s get down to the nitty-gritty.
    Were you poor , would you choose to raise your children in “communist” Cuba or capitalist South Africa ?

    • Moses Patterson

      That’s an easy one. I would
      always choose that country where through education, hard work and the freedom
      to decide the destiny for myself and my family, I am able to change my
      circumstance. Today, that means South Africa. Anti-capitalists such as yourself
      hope for a government to do all the heavy lifting to improve the quality of
      life. I just want government to level the playing field and then get out of my
      way. I don’t want a ration book, I want access to jobs that pay a living wage.
      I don’t want the government to pay for my health care, I simply need government
      to ensure that the cost of decent health care is affordable. I don’t need the
      government to limit my internet access to protect me from idiots who espouse
      failed government systems like the socialism that exists in your fantasies. I
      simply need government to guarantee my right to the government of my choosing.

  • Moses Patterson

    Your posts reflect your dislike of capitalism, the majority of the world’s economies, and even talk radio. It would suck to be you.

    • John Goodrich

      On the other hand , I love democracy and the truth .
      Capitalism is the antithesis of democracy and talk radio is entertainment for very uneducated people .
      Do notice that neither Rush nor Beck have guests from the left to debate their idiocies and all those whom would intellectually embarrass Limbaugh are not permitted on the air by his screener . Hannity does not let opposition speakers talk by constantly interrupting them . He shut off Christopher Hitchens microphone when Hitchens was on his show.
      All of them are free to spout off stuff that would be shredded in formal debate with an educated opponent which is why they do not permit it.
      Unfortunately for you, you have no Bo Snerdly to screen me out and my regular shredding of your preposterous arguments shows how easy it is to put the lie to those talk show entertainers you parrot .
      BTW, just where do you get your information ?
      Can you recommend publications, or media outlets or other sources that back up your stuff ?
      My main source is ZNet/ZCommunications along with TomDispatch and several of the websites listed at TomDispatch for the truth but do listen to NPR ( National Pentagon Radio ) Public BS ( PBS ) Fox and some of the network stuff on a daily basis .
      I always like to compare how the moron right, the corporate right media and the left (Z is left and NOT liberal/progressive ) treat the same story.
      You should try it some time .

      • Moses Patterson

        My information sources? With regards to my comments here at HT, I LIVED in Cuba. I am married to a Cuban woman. I talk to other Cubans almost every day. Given this is a website about CUBA, I am guessing my “sources” trump ZNet/ZCommunications. Talking to Cubans about
        Cuba, you should try it some time.

        • John Goodrich

          That was not a very adroit avoidance of the question Moses but then I suspect you’re rather ashamed to admit where you get your information and better to have me think that you’re a moron than to tell me where you get the bulk of your thinking from and have that thought confirmed. .
          We’ve discussed a great many things here beyond life in Cuba and you’re just as disinformed on a great many other things as well.
          And…since you never read anything at ZNet as I do a great deal of stuff from the right , you’re hardly in a position to tell me that your sources trump what is presented daily at ZNet.
          See, I’ve dealt with the far right for years and I know from vast experience that they can’t deal with the cognitive dissonance ( brain strain) that arises when their fantasies collide with hard truths.
          A number of studies have shown that those, like you, when confronted with incontrovertible facts, block them out and retreat ever deeper into their already existing and erroneous thinking .
          To be fair , the studies also said that some on the left also do this but the overwhelming majority of those who do so are on the (erroneous) right.
          You have plenty of company.

  • emagicmtman

    Meanwhile, next door in Zimbabwe, where whites were pushed off “their” lands and forced to emmigrate, the country has become an economic basket case, with inflation running in the thousands of percentages each year, or rather, each month. Many of its black citizens have also been forced to emmigrate to South Africa, both to work, and to smuggle food and products back in that have largely disappeared from the shelves in Harare. In South Africa the post-apartheid leadership has had to compromise and make the best of a bad deal. Realistically, are there better–or even other–alternatives? In the 1920′s and 1930′s the Soviet Union went on a forced march of primitive accumulation in order to build a modern industrial state–but at what price?! OTOH, modern, multi-national capital may exact just as dreadful a price (but for that matter, they are doing a pretty good job here in the U.S.A. of destroying both middle- and working-class.